Recent Auto Insurance Fraud Cases in Pennsylvania: April–May 2025

Insurance fraud remains a significant concern in Pennsylvania, impacting both insurers and policyholders. The following are notable cases from April and May 2025 that highlight the ongoing challenges in combating fraudulent activities.

1. Staged Hit-and-Run in Hanover

Two women from eastern Pennsylvania were charged with felony offenses after allegedly staging a hit-and-run accident in Hanover to support a fraudulent insurance claim totaling $30,000. Surveillance footage contradicted their reports, leading to charges of filing false claims. Read more.

2. $300K Fraud Scheme in Cumberland County

A complex scheme involving identity theft and fraudulent insurance claims resulted in over $300,000 in losses. The final defendant was sentenced in April 2025, concluding a significant case that underscores the importance of vigilant insurance practices. Read more.

3. Immediate Claim Post-Policy Purchase

A man in Grove City filed a car accident claim just eight minutes after purchasing an insurance policy. Investigations revealed the vehicle had been damaged prior to the policy's activation, leading to fraud charges. Read more.

4. Legal Dispute: Carr v. State Farm

Anthony Carr filed a lawsuit against State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company in April 2025, alleging issues related to insurance claims. The case is currently under review in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania. Read more.

These cases highlight the ongoing efforts to detect and prevent insurance fraud in Pennsylvania. Policyholders are encouraged to report suspicious activities and ensure accurate information in all insurance dealings.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. For legal advice or more detailed information, please consult official sources or legal professionals.